Spencer Engineers, Inc.

Forensic Engineering & Expert Witness Services

Registered Professional Mechanical Engineer

HVAC & Plumbing
Registered Professional Electrical Engineer

Lighting & Power Distribution
Emergency Power Generation
Construction Contract Administration

Construction Cost Estimating

Life Cycle Cost Analysis

Energy Consumption Analysis

 

4635 Southwest Freeway - Suite 900
Houston, Texas 77027-7104
713-621-2482

1-800-383-0685
gspencer@spencerae.com

 

 
Home
Firm Profile
Engineers
Design Disciplines
Areas Of Practice
Client List
Projects

 

existing HVAC systems analysis

SEI mechanical and electrical engineers are hands-on experienced with analyzing existing HVAC systems, diagnosing operational problems, and proposing long term and short term solutions to these problems.  Our staff of engineers are particularly well acquainted in building operations and communicate very well with operating and maintenance personnel.  You will find that our staff is at home with tools and instruments, as compared to the clean hands ivory tower type of engineer or architect.  This attitude generally shows through and makes our personnel more compatible with your operating and maintenance personnel.  We always take the time to explain any changes in operating and maintenance procedures to your personnel so that they will fully understand and believe in any procedures that we recommend.  SEI has extensive experience determining HVAC system requirements.  SEI has had in-house HVAC load calculating capability since 1979.  SEI engineers have performed analysis of the following HVAC systems:

A.  LACKLAND AFB HVAC STUDY BUILDINGS 1351, 1250, 1354, 1251, 1355, 6329 and 6359 - Sept, 2002 - Project No. MPLS-00-1062 Lackland AFB, Texas 78236-5253 - We performed a formal study and written report to determine why these recently air conditioned buildings did not control the indoor humidity properly, and was growing mold on the indoor surfaces.  We then prepared a report to correct the apparatus configurations so that the systems would have inherent humidity control plus positive humidity control when abnormal conditions occur.  Abnormal conditions might be when someone holds the doors open for extended periods of time, or during system startup after a power failure or system shutdown. 
All of these buildings have extreme mold and mildew problems resulting from the high room relative humidity that is normally present indoors since the HVAC systems replacement. The resulting high relative humidity has caused mold, mildew and rust on the relatively new walls, ceiling grids, the ceiling supply air diffusers, and the return air grilles. Most of these buildings have recently installed new HVAC systems, and the occupants refused to work in these buildings due to the humidity and mold problems.
The problem was with the basic design configuration of the recently installed new HVAC apparatus which did not feature inherent humidity control or even positive control for removal of humidity during abnormal or upset conditions. The existing systems will require that the chiller be operated at essentially full load whenever the building cooling requirement is less than 90% of the full capacity for humidity control, and that the boiler also be operated at all times to reheat the room air supply sufficiently to prevent the rooms from getting too cold. The annual operating costs of this system if operated for humidity control would be several times the cost of a modified apparatus with face & by-pass or maybe return air by-pass to the fan section.
We proposed to vary the apparatus leaving air temperature by blending dehumidified return air in the draw-through fan section as required to not overcool the occupied space. This will eliminate the reheat requirement. We recommend cutting an opening into the fan plenum and adding a motor operated damper to allow dehumidified return air (RA) to enter the fan plenum without passing through the cooling coil except when it is needed to cool the occupied space, or when dehumidification and reheat is required. We will remove the control valve from the chilled water coil and allow the chilled water coil to circulate uncontrolled and have the cooling coil leaving air temperature to be constant at or below the desired dew point. This removal of the chilled water control valve will also decrease the possibility of wintertime chilled water coil freezing, if the chilled water pumps are operated at all temperatures below freezing. Dehumidification and reheat will not be required except under extreme conditions, such as when someone blocks the exterior doors open. The modified apparatus would have inherent control of the maximum room relative humidity due to the revised configuration with inherent maximum dew point control. Rough estimations for office occupancy for San Antonio gives 2200 full load equivalent hours of cooling capacity operation.
The occupants complain that the rooms at the ends of the duct runs of the recently air conditioned "I" buildings have no air flow. The contract MPLS 96-8011 drawings indicate that the ducts were sized at constant friction without using any static regain consideration. Speeding up the fan to overcome the additional static friction from the first air outlet to the last air outlet and would be less expensive than replacing the ductwork with larger ductwork, but would cause additional fan noise in the rooms closest to the fan rooms.
The exterior of these wooden framed buildings have been up-graded or dressed up by the application of EFIS on top of the existing exterior wood siding. This was probably intended to change the appearance of these structures and give them the appearance of modern office buildings. EIFS added to new or existing wood substrate sometimes causes the wood to rot and fail. These failures normally occur within eight to ten years. EFIS added to wooden framed structures has caused many failures around the country, and many lawsuits. The moisture trapped behind the EFIS panels in the wood substrate causes the wood substrate to rot. We recommend modifying the existing apparatus to maintain a constant chilled water cooling coil leaving dew point.

B.  LACKLAND AFB CHILLED WATER PLANT PIPING REVISIONS - 1998 - We performed a study to determine why the plant chilled water would not circulate the water to the buildings properly, and then prepared drawings to correct the piping so that the piping would flow to the buildings in the quantity needed.

C.  POSTAL SERVICE - Main Post Office, Houston - Replace open drive motor, replace transmission, revise piping for variable chilled water flow, reconfigure plant for primary-secondary pumping, start-up & commissioning, operating procedures, and balancing.

D.  MDACC - SMITH RESEARCH BUILDING - HOUSTON, TEXAS - We Studied and documented the existing HVAC, Electrical Service, Air, Vacuum, Deionized Water, Instrument Air, Steam Supply, Chilled Water Supply, and other services to the laboratory.  We documented the present, future, and ultimate requirements for these utilities as required to serve the existing and proposed laboratories, and the future ultimate building utility requirements for these services.  Our study documented specific modifications to the building that allowed the building to be fully developed into laboratory space plus the addition of 60,000 SF of new research laboratory space. 

E.   EXXON PRODUCTION RESEARCH LABORATORY BUILDING - 1976 - We performed an analysis of the HVAC system and recommended energy conservation measures such as Variable Volume Chemical Hood Exhaust, Chilled Water Reheat for OSA Make-up, and several other unique HVAC modifications for that project.

F.   SEI has performed many analysis of small existing HVAC systems for the US Postal Service.  Contact Mr. Marshall Cantor (713) 226-3471 with the USPS.  SEI has all of the tools & instruments to analyze HVAC systems, and regularly uses these instruments to determine non operation problems, and operational problems with HVAC systems.  SEI has corrected small problems if they are easy to fix.

1.            COLLEGE STATION PO - REPLACE CHILLER - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471     REPLACE CHILLER - 1994 - $38,686

2.            VIDOR PO - REPLACE HVAC EQUIPMENT - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - REPLACE HVAC EQUIPMENT - 1994 - $21,000

3.            MEMORIAL PARK STA - REPLACE CHILLER - USPS - SIMS (214) 819-7236 - REPLACE CHILLER - 1994 - $98,360

4.            BAYTOWN MPO COMPRESSOR REPL - USPS - SIMS (214) 819-7236 - REPLACE COMPRESSOR      1993 - $5,350

5.            LAKE JACKSON, TX MPO - REPLACE HVAC - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - REPLACE HVAC EQUIPMENT - 1993

6.            ROY ROYALE STA - REPLACE HVAC - USPS - SIMS (214) 819-7236 - REPLACE HVAC EQUIPMENT - 1993 - $97,000

7.            GREENS NORTH STATION, TX - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - EMERGENCY GAS LINE REPAIR - 1993

8.            LONG POINT STA HVAC REPLACEMENT - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - REPLACE HVAC EQUIPMENT - 1993

9.            ORANGE, TX MPO - REPLACE CHILLERS - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - REPLACE CHILLERS - 1993

10.        PASADENA COOLING TOWER REPAIRS - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - HVAC R&A REPAIRS - 1993

11.        FOSTER PLACE STATION - HVAC REPLACE - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

12.        DENVER HARBOR STA - HVAC REPLACE - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

13.        S POST OAK STATION - HVAC REPLACE     USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471     HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

14.        MISSOURI CITY STATION - HVAC REPLACE - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

15.        BEECHNUT STATION - HVAC REPLACE - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

16.        WESTFIELD STATION - HVAC REPLACE       USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - HVAC EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT - 1993

17.        HOUSTON, TX MPO - CH REPAIRS - USPS - CANTOR (713) 226-3471 - CHILLED WATER SYSTEM MOD - 1992

G.  preventative maintenance plans and manuals:  SEI prepares operation & maintenance manuals for projects that have other than normal operating and maintenance procedures.  Normal projects without complicated operating or complicated maintenance procedure requirements can be documented by the construction contractor.  SEI specifications always include a maintenance program outline, operational program outline, and other scope requirements so that the contractor fills in the blanks with the equipment that he selects to install, and submits the completed data for the AE review.  SEI has extensive experience reviewing contractor prepared O&M plans and manuals.  SEI mechanical and electrical engineers are hands-on experienced with analyzing existing HVAC systems, diagnosing operational problems, and proposing long term and short term solutions to these problems.  Our staff of engineers (and architects) are particularly well acquainted in building operations and communicate very well with operating and maintenance personnel.  You will find that our staff is at home with tools and instruments, as compared to the clean hands ivory tower type of engineer.  This attitude generally shows through and makes our personnel more compatible with your operating and maintenance personnel.  We always take the time to explain any changes in operating and maintenance procedures to your personnel so that they will fully understand and believe in any procedures that we recommend.

 

 

 

 

THESE ARE HYPERLINKS TO OTHER AREAS OF OUR EXPERTISE IN OUR WEBSITE THAT MIGHT BE OF INTEREST TO YOU

ANALYSIS OF EXISTING HVAC SYSTEMS         APARTMENT EXPERIENCE         ARMY PROJECTS         AVIATION PROJECTS         BANK PROJECTS         COMMUNICATIONS SECURITY SYSTEMS              Computer Assisted Designs       Construction Quality Control              CONSULTANTS         Construction cost Estimating               CRYOGENICS PROJECTS         data processing EQUIPMENT space planning         DESIGN QUALITY CONTROL PLAN         DEPARTMENT OF STATE PROJECTS         Design Quality Control Plan            EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES        ELECTRICAL            EMERGENCY POWER GENERATION                 ENERGY MANAGEMENT       ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING          EXPERT WITNESS          EXXON USA PROJECTS          FIRE PROTECTION         FORENSIC ENGINEERING          FOREIGN COUNTRY PROJECTS            HIGH BAY CONSTRUCTION         HIGH RISE BUILDINGS         HOTELS         INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION         INSTRUMENTATION         INSTRUMENTATION AND CONTROLS          LIBRARIES         ECONOMIC LIFE CYCLE COST ANALYSIS       MECHANICAL           MEDICAL PROJECTS         METRIC DESIGN         MILITARY FAMILY HOUSING         MILITARY PROJECTS         MODIFICATION, REPAIR, RENOVATION, OR ADDITIONS TO EXISTING FACILITIES             MUNITIONS PROJECTS                 NASA PROJECTS              NAVY PROJECTS           NIMA PROJECTS          OFFICE BUILDINGS              offshore platform Construction           ORDINANCE PROJECTS              PHYSICAL SECURITY SYSTEMS              PLUMBING         POSTAL PROJECTS                predominant energy use studies           PUBLIC FACILITIES              REFRIGERATION PROJECTS               RELIGIOUS PROJECTS             RENOVATIONS TO HISTORICAL BUILDINGS             REPORTS              RESTAURANTS              RETAIL FACILITIES             SECURITY SYSTEMS                 SEISMIC RESISTANT PROJECT DESIGN             SPACE SIMULATION FACILITIES             TELECOMMUNICATIONS DESIGN             USAF PROJECTS                WAREHOUSE  PROJECTS